‘Evidentiary Value of WhatsApp Messages’

By

 

In today's era of information technology the focus of country is on digital India. Use of science and technology by criminals, in commission of crime, is increasing day by day and to deal with such crime and criminals, it is very important that the investigating agencies must be aware and trained about such technologies. Collection of scientific evidence is important aspect of crime investigation, police officers involved in collection of direct evidence, are hardly trained in collection of scientific evidence. Another issue is that there is neither specific guideline of court nor any specific law to deal with scientific investigation. By the Information Technology Act, 2000 certain amendments were done in Indian Evidence Act, 1872 in regard to admissibility of scientific evidence; however that is subject to some condition laid down in the Act. During investigation investigating agencies collect a number of scientific evidence like tape recorded conversation, mobile communication, Facebook, WhatsApp messages, string operation, polygraph test, DNA evidence and so on, however how much weightage shall be given to such evidence is subject to controversy. The main thrust of this article is to analyse WhatsApp messages as evidence and to find out how much evidentiary value is given by courts to such messages. Whether such scientific evidence may be concluded as a conclusive proof or not, needs to be analyised. Since there is no specific guideline or test which determine the accuracy or scientific validity of such evidence. Author will suggest some factors to be taken into consideration while appreciating such evidence.

In regard to WhatsApp message problem is this that whatsApp messages are not stored on server so once message has been send the receiver may very easily edit the messages and if any controversy arise in future in regard to content of message and if it is not saved in the senders mobile then it will be very difficult to prove what message had been sent and receiver may present edited message very easily because once WhatsApp message is delivered it is no more saved on sever like general mobile messages.

In Rakesh Kumar Singla vs Union of India (CRM-M no. 23220 of 2020) relying on WhatsApp chats court granted the bail in an NDPS Act. Gujarat High Court in Chirag Deepak Bhai Sulekha vs State of Gujarat (Criminal Misc. Application No. 18834 of 2020) granted bail on the basis of WhatsApp chats.  In regard to forwarded message on WhatsApp Delhi High Court in National lawyers campaign for judicial reforms and reforms vs union of India (2019 SCC OnLine SC 411) held that forwarded message cannot be treated as evidence it cannot be treated as 'document' under Indian Evidence Act without having original of forwarded message. In Sri P.  padmanabh vs Syndicate Bank limited Karnataka (2008 AIR (Kar) 42) High Court held that if computer itself was not in proper condition means it was malfunctioning then output or any information received from such computer cannot be treated as an evidence and should not be relied upon.  On the basis of WhatsApp chat Delhi High Court in Ritu vs state (2018 SCC online Delhi 12914)  released the accused of rape. In the same line   students of Jindal global University were punished for gang raping and blackmailing their juniors. The onviction was based on WhatsApp chats admitted as evidence (Misc. No. 23 962 of 2017).

In case of Girwar Singh vs CBI ((2016) 5 RCR (Cri) 757) Court appointed committee to check the authenticity of electronic evidence and the committee found that evidence was not the original one but the copy of original one and the evidence was copied a number of time in different devices ultimately Delhi High Court did not accepted such messages as evidence in the case.  Bombay High Court in SBI cards installment and station private limited versus Rohit Jadhav (2018 SCC OnLine Bom 1262) held that if blue tick is appeared then it will be considered that receiver has opened (and read) the message. If message was notice then it will be presumed that notice was served.   It is important to note that court did not consider the other situation in this scenario it is quite possible that in the member of the family may have opened the message or it is also quite was well that in general notice is not served through WhatsApp because if Court is admitting such mode of notice then there must be a provision in law for such mode of notice.

In recent months a number of media highlighted case has been charge-sheeted on the basis of WhatsApp messages, whether it is TRP conspiracy between republic editor in chief Arnab Goswami and (BARC) CEO partho Das Gupta or whether it is case of North East Delhi by JNU students Sarjil imam and pinjra Tod activist or it is Sushant Singh Rajput case.

So it can be concluded that for a admissibility of such messages the device must be in good condition and must be in regular use again the sender of such message must have an intention to send those messages then only such messages can be treated as evidence.

 Sudhir Kumar Dwivedi

Assistant Professor, JEMTEC School of Law

www.jimsgn.org

Sudhir Kumar Dwivedi

Assistant Professor, JEMTEC School of Law

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Teacher As: Critical Pedagogue

By
Education is not only a process of cognitive development. It is a process of overall development of the child. The whole teaching learning process consist with three important components i.e student, teacher and curriculum. In the process of curriculum construction, evaluation and feedbacks are an important aspect to redesign the curriculum. Evaluation cannot be made on the basis of academic achievement of the students. Teacher should play an important role in the construction of curriculum as well as transaction of curriculum. Thus there is a need that teacher should take initiative to evaluate the whole education system as a Critical pedagogue. It is an ability to evaluate our teaching and the practices prevailing in existing education system critically in relation to methods and practices adopted by the teacher to teach concern pedagogical subjects. Ira Shor defines “ Critical pedagogy is habits of thought, reading, writing and speaking which go beneath surface meaning, first impr
Read more

ROLE CONFLICT PROBLEM AMONG WORKING WOMEN

By
Women of India have marked their significant presence in the world in various fields. They have been given the status of power and prestige in India.    Indian women has got much more significance in today’s developing times. Where until lately, they were shadowed by patriarchal dominance, the contemporary women in India have moved beyond all social boundaries to emerge as triumphant leaders of tomorrow. Not only has She taken up courageous roles in society, her own individuality as a ‘woman’ has now got an improvised meaning. The world has changed for females in India now. The daughters are pursuing successful ambitions in the male dominated corporate scenario and mothers are taking up flextime jobs to showcase their exceptional managerial talent. Today, our women have stepped out to become bread earners of the family. Although the trend is yet developing in India, The IT-BPO sector is becoming a female dominated industry in India with a significant number of capable and qualified f
Read more

Rights and obligations of Issuer, Participant and Beneficial owner under the Depository Act, 1996

By
As per section 17 of depository Act the rights and obligations of the depositories, participants and the issuers whose securities are dealt with by a depository shall be specified by the regulations. Under the Depository Act, 1996 depository means a company formed and registered under the Companies Act, 1956, and which has been granted a certificate of registration by SEBI under sub-section (1A) of Section 12 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 ). (Section 2(1) (e)) Work of Depository- The word ‘depositary’ is defined as “the party of the institution (company) receiving a deposit. A depository holds securities (like shares, debentures, bonds, Government Securities, units etc.) of investors in electronic form. Besides holding securities, a depository also provides services related to transactions in securities. It acts as a trustee of the owner since the securities are entrusted with him in trust. He is also the agent of the owner of the securities. Thus
Read more