ESSENTIAL RELIGIOUS PRACTICES DOCTRINE AND ITS EFFECT ON SECULARISM

By

 India being a land of diverse religions and cultures, there are various religions namely Hinduism, Islam, Christianity, Jainism, Sikhism and Buddhism. Therefore, to avoid any conflict in such multireligious nation, the concept of secularism was adopted. Secularism in simple words means state recognizes no religion but respect all religions. The word 'secular' was added in the Preamble in the year 1976 in Indian Constitution. Although the concept of secularism is adopted from western countries but India follows such secularism model with slight deviation such as state interference is allowed in case of secular practices associated with religion under Article 25 of Indian Constitution. Thus, Indian Judiciary has played important role in reshaping the elements of secularism through Essential Religious Practices Doctrine (ERP) as evolved in case of Commissioner, Hindu Religious Endowments, Madras v. Sri Lakshimindra Thirtha Swamiar of Sri Shirur Mutt. This article throws a light upon how Indian Judiciary through ERP doctrine causes discourse to secularism and has reshaped the meaning of freedom of religion as well as secularism. At the end author also gives suggestion of removing ERP doctrine so that real meaning of secularism is restored in India. 

The main argument against usage of  ERP doctrine lies in creating a bridge between religious practice that will receive protection and secular practices which will not receive protection under Article 25 of Indian Constitution. Indian Judiciary which should act as a constitutional body has now taken up theology role to bring up social reforms irrespective of secular nation. For instance, the Apex Court has recently applied ERP test in Shayara Bano v. Union of India (triple talaq case) to declare instantaneous triple talaq (talaq-e-biddat) as unconstitutional because it is not an essential religious practice of Islam.  Also. in this case, the court determined that Triple Talaq is not only sinful and contrary to the Quran’s teachings but also that it is not an appropriate religious ritual. Now the question arises When giving divorce is not illegal under other religions such as Hinduism, Christianity, or Islam, why is Judiciary tried to make such a rule under Muslim law.

Secularism in India should be examined in a flexible and wider approach to provide freedom of religion for all groups and communities. Indian Secularism should ideally be pluralistic and flexible so as to cater to the needs of all persons. Attempting to apply secularism in such a manner so as to make all religious minorities and tribal to fall within the Hindu fold would destroy their identities and the national aspirations of the Constitution. The Court’s evolution of the Essential Religious Functions test is an interventionist approach and should be removed.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Teacher As: Critical Pedagogue

By
Education is not only a process of cognitive development. It is a process of overall development of the child. The whole teaching learning process consist with three important components i.e student, teacher and curriculum. In the process of curriculum construction, evaluation and feedbacks are an important aspect to redesign the curriculum. Evaluation cannot be made on the basis of academic achievement of the students. Teacher should play an important role in the construction of curriculum as well as transaction of curriculum. Thus there is a need that teacher should take initiative to evaluate the whole education system as a Critical pedagogue. It is an ability to evaluate our teaching and the practices prevailing in existing education system critically in relation to methods and practices adopted by the teacher to teach concern pedagogical subjects. Ira Shor defines “ Critical pedagogy is habits of thought, reading, writing and speaking which go beneath surface meaning, first impr...
Read more

ROLE CONFLICT PROBLEM AMONG WORKING WOMEN

By
Women of India have marked their significant presence in the world in various fields. They have been given the status of power and prestige in India.    Indian women has got much more significance in today’s developing times. Where until lately, they were shadowed by patriarchal dominance, the contemporary women in India have moved beyond all social boundaries to emerge as triumphant leaders of tomorrow. Not only has She taken up courageous roles in society, her own individuality as a ‘woman’ has now got an improvised meaning. The world has changed for females in India now. The daughters are pursuing successful ambitions in the male dominated corporate scenario and mothers are taking up flextime jobs to showcase their exceptional managerial talent. Today, our women have stepped out to become bread earners of the family. Although the trend is yet developing in India, The IT-BPO sector is becoming a female dominated industry in India with a significant number of capable a...
Read more

Rights and obligations of Issuer, Participant and Beneficial owner under the Depository Act, 1996

By
As per section 17 of depository Act the rights and obligations of the depositories, participants and the issuers whose securities are dealt with by a depository shall be specified by the regulations. Under the Depository Act, 1996 depository means a company formed and registered under the Companies Act, 1956, and which has been granted a certificate of registration by SEBI under sub-section (1A) of Section 12 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 ). (Section 2(1) (e)) Work of Depository- The word ‘depositary’ is defined as “the party of the institution (company) receiving a deposit. A depository holds securities (like shares, debentures, bonds, Government Securities, units etc.) of investors in electronic form. Besides holding securities, a depository also provides services related to transactions in securities. It acts as a trustee of the owner since the securities are entrusted with him in trust. He is also the agent of the owner of the securities. Thus...
Read more